N6238P accident

NTSB CEN11CA344 · 2011-05-17 · Carbondale, IL · near PJY

Docket — crew, injuries and powerplant

Summary

The certified flight instructor (CFI) reported that the student pilot had failed the Private Pilot check ride the previous week and that the accident flight was a flight review for the student. The student pilot performed a go-around on the first landing attempt because the airplane was too high on the final landing approach. On the final leg during the second approach, the airplane was on the proper glideslope and at the appropriate airspeed. The airplane was left of centerline and about 5 feet above the runway when the student pilot initiated the flare. The CFI reported that the student pilot suddenly relinquished the flight controls without warning, and the CFI attempted to salvage the landing. The student pilot reported that he relinquished the controls to the CFI and stated, “Your controls.” The right wing tip contacted the runway, which resulted in substantial damage to two ribs in the outboard section of the wing. The CFI did not recognize that the wing tip struck the runway, so the flight returned to the departure airport. The damage to the wing was discovered during the postflight inspection of the airplane.

Full narrative

The certified flight instructor (CFI) reported that the student pilot had failed the Private Pilot check ride the previous week, and that the accident flight was a flight review for the student pilot. The CFI reported that the student pilot performed the ground reference maneuvers and "lost" procedures within the Private Pilot standards. The student pilot performed a go-around on the first landing attempt because the airplane was too high on final. On the final leg during the second approach, the airplane was on and airspeed. The airplane was left of centerline and about 5 feet above the runway when the student pilot initiated the flare. The CFI reported that the student pilot suddenly relinquished the flight controls without warning, and the CFI attempted to "salvage" the landing. The student pilot reported that he relinquished the controls to the CFI and stated, "Your controls." The right wingtip contacted the runway which resulted in substantial damage to two ribs in the outboard section of the wing. The CFI did not recognize that the wingtip struck the runway, so the flight returned to the departure airport. The damage to the wing was discovered during the postflight inspection of the airplane.

Probable cause

The student pilot's relinquishing of the flight controls during the landing flare and the flight instructor's delay in taking remedial action. The National Transportation Safety Board determined the probable cause of this accident.

Circumstances

Event type
Accident
Highest injury
None
Weather conditions
Visual Meteorological Cond
Light condition
Day
Sky condition
NONE
Ceiling (ft)
0
Visibility (sm)
10
Wind direction
350
Wind speed (kt)
10
Temperature (F)
57
Nearest airport
Pinckneyville-Du Quoin Airport
Distance from field
0.0
Airport elevation
400

Aircraft

RegistrationMakeModelDamageFAR part
N6238P — — SUBS 091

Sequence of events

#OccurrencePhase
1 Landing-flare/touchdown Abrupt maneuver defining Cruise
2 Landing-flare/touchdown Abnormal runway contact Cruise

Findings

Finding
Personnel issues-Action/decision-Action-Incorrect action performance-Student pilot cause
Personnel issues-Action/decision-Action-Delayed action-Instructor/check pilot cause