N79MS accident

NTSB WPR20LA306 · 2020-08-19 · Upland, CA · near CCB

Docket — crew, injuries and powerplant

Summary

After landing, as the pilot was taxiing back to the runway for another takeoff, the right landing gear collapsed, and the right wing struck the runway resulting in substantial damage. Examination of the landing gear bolts revealed they failed due to reverse bending fatigue cracking. The size of the fatigue cracking area on the fracture surfaces versus the overstress area indicated the fatigue likely grew over time under low-to-moderate stress. The occurrence of the fatigue cracking on all the hex-head bolts and the similarities of the fatigue cracking areas on the fracture surfaces were consistent with some amount of movement on that side of the landing gear, which indicates there was likely an issue with preloading of the bolts.

Full narrative

On August 17, 2020, at 2005 Pacific daylight time, a Piper PA-28-181 airplane, N79MS, sustained substantial damage when it was involved in an accident near Upland, California. The two pilots were not injured. The airplane was operated as a Title 14 Code of Federal Regulations Part 91 personal flight.

According to both pilots, the private pilot was undergoing a check flight for his commercial certificate. After the private pilot completed a landing on runway 24 at Cable Airport (CCB), he was taxing back to the runway when the airplane’s right landing gear collapsed and folded under the wing. As a result, the wing dropped to the ground and the airplane slowly veered to the right and skidded to a stop.

The right wing sustained substantial damage to the wing spar.

Nine pieces of bolts from the collapsed right landing gear were submitted to the NTSB Materials Laboratory for further examination. The pieces included one full round head bolt, one separated round head, two shanks from round-head bolts, two separated hex heads, two shanks from hex heads, and one hex head with a portion of shank still attached.

The examination revealed the fracture surfaces of the four separated hex-head bolts were relatively flat and had crack arrest marks (aka beach marks) consistent with fatigue cracking. Small circular areas of rougher features consistent with overstress from the final fracture of the bolts were also observed.

Ratchet marks consistent with multiple fatigue cracking initiation sites were observed around the outer diameter of the shanks. The fatigue cracking progressed toward the center of the bolts. Two main areas of fatigue cracking propagating from opposite sides of the bolt outer diameters were observed on the fracture surfaces, which is consistent with reverse bending fatigue cracking. Three of the bolts had one fatigue cracking area larger than the other, which indicated the fatigue cracking on those bolts grew from one side of the bolts initially before the opposite side fatigue cracking began progressing. The fourth bolt had opposing fatigue cracking areas of approximately the same size, indicating the fatigue cracking on the two sides started progressing around the same time.

Probable cause

The failure of the right landing gear due to fatigue cracking. The National Transportation Safety Board determined the probable cause of this accident.

Circumstances

Event type
Accident
Highest injury
None
Weather conditions
Visual Meteorological Cond
Light condition
Night
Sky condition
NONE
Ceiling (ft)
0
Visibility (sm)
10
Wind direction
270
Wind speed (kt)
10
Temperature (F)
95
Nearest airport
Cable Airport
Distance from field
0.0
Airport elevation
1443

Aircraft

RegistrationMakeModelDamageFAR part
N79MS — — SUBS 091

Sequence of events

#OccurrencePhase
1 Taxi-to runway Landing gear collapse defining Taxi

Findings

Finding
Aircraft-Aircraft oper/perf/capability-Performance/control parameters-Directional control-Attain/maintain not possible factor
Aircraft-Aircraft systems-Landing gear system-Main landing gear-Fatigue/wear/corrosion cause