N1957P Cheek Carroll HATZ/CHEEK accident

NTSB CEN23LA083 · 2023-01-15 · Brashear , TX

Docket — crew, injuries and powerplant

Summary

The pilot reported a gradual loss of engine power during cruise flight. He applied carburetor heat when the engine began running rough, which seemed to make the situation worse. Eventually, the available engine power was insufficient to maintain altitude and it became clear the airplane would not be able to reach the destination airport. The pilot executed a forced landing to a field; however, he flared too high and landed hard. The airframe sustained substantial damage to both wings and the fuselage. A postaccident engine examination revealed minor anomalies with respect to the carburetor heat system, and those anomalies may have slightly reduced the effectiveness of the carburetor heat when applied. The remaining anomalies identified during the engine examination were not consistent with a gradual loss of engine power and did not contribute to the accident. Meteorological conditions were conducive to the formation of carburetor icing during cruise flight. Based on the available information, it is likely that the formation of carburetor icing, which the carburetor heat system was unable to adequately remove, resulted in the loss of engine power. In addition, the hard landing that occurred during the forced landing may have increased the extent of damage to the airframe.

Full narrative

On January 15, 2023, about 0930 central standard time, a Hatz Classic airplane, N1957P, was substantially damaged when it was involved in an accident near Brashear, Texas. The pilot was not injured. The airplane was operated as a Title 14 Code of Federal Regulations Part 91 personal flight.

The pilot reported a gradual loss of engine power during cruise flight. He applied carburetor heat when the engine began running rough, which seemed to make the situation worse. Eventually, the available engine power was insufficient to maintain altitude and it became clear the airplane would not be able to reach the destination airport. He executed a forced landing to a field; however, he flared “too high” and landed hard. The airframe sustained damage to both wings and the fuselage.

A postaccident engine examination noted the carburetor heat ducting appeared “insufficient for proper airflow” and the carburetor heat control arm was not fully engaged. The mechanic estimated the carburetor heat installation was about 90% functional. In addition, the electric conductivity between the magneto P-lead and the cockpit ignition switch was intermittent, and 2 ignition leads exhibited minor damage. Otherwise, the engine examination was unremarkable.

Meteorological conditions were conducive to the formation of carburetor icing during cruise flight. In his statement, the pilot noted the possibility of carburetor icing as the reason for the loss of engine power.

Probable cause

A partial loss of engine power due to the formation of carburetor ice, which resulted in the inability to maintain altitude and the subsequent hard forced landing. The National Transportation Safety Board determined the probable cause of this accident.

Circumstances

Event type
Accident
Highest injury
None
Weather conditions
Visual Meteorological Cond
Light condition
Day
Sky condition
BKN
Ceiling (ft)
1000
Visibility (sm)
10
Wind direction
170
Wind speed (kt)
11
Temperature (F)
52
Nearest airport
N/A
Distance from field
0.0

Aircraft

RegistrationMakeModelDamageFAR part
N1957P CHEEK CARROLL HATZ/CHEEK SUBS 091

Sequence of events

#OccurrencePhase
1 Enroute Loss of engine power (total) Climb
2 Emergency descent Off-field or emergency landing Descent
3 Landing-flare/touchdown Hard landing Cruise
4 Enroute Fuel related defining Climb

Findings

Finding
Environmental issues-Conditions/weather/phenomena-Temp/humidity/pressure-Conducive to carburetor icing-Effect on equipment cause