N503DN accident
NTSB DCA24FA299 · 2024-09-10 · College Park, GA · near KATL
Docket — crew, injuries and powerplant
Summary
As Delta Air Lines flight 295 (DAL295) was taxiing behind Endeavor Air dba Delta Connection flight 5526 (EDV5526), the right wingtip of DAL295 impacted the vertical stabilizer of EDV5526 at Hartsfield-Jackson Atlanta International Airport (ATL), Atlanta, Georgia, resulting in separation of the vertical stabilizer. EDV5526 was holding short of runway 8R on taxiway H waiting for a takeoff clearance as DAL295 was taxiing on taxiway E to hold short of taxiway V. EDV5526 stopped about 56 ft from the hold short line, resulting in insufficient clearance for an A350 to pass behind it on taxiway E. At the time of the collision, the captain of DAL295 was focused on ensuring the airplane’s left wingtip would not impinge on traffic exiting taxiway V while the first officer (FO) of DAL295 was locating taxiway V on the navigation display and electronic flight bag (EFB). As a result, neither the captain nor the FO of DAL295 identified the loss of clearance between their right wingtip and the empennage of EDV5526.
Full narrative
On September 10, 2024, about 1007 eastern daylight time (EDT), DAL295, an Airbus A350-941, N503DN, collided with EDV5526, a Mitsubishi Heavy Industries (MHI) RJ CL-600-2D24 (CRJ-900), N302PQ, while taxiing for departure at Hartsfield-Jackson Atlanta International Airport (ATL), Atlanta, Georgia. The 15 crewmembers and 221 passengers on board DAL295 were uninjured. Three crewmembers and 56 passengers on board EDV5526 were uninjured and one crewmember sustained minor injuries. DAL295 was a scheduled international passenger flight operating under the provisions of Title 14 Code of Federal Regulations (CFR) Part 121 from ATL to Haneda Airport (HND), Tokyo, Japan. EDV5526 was a scheduled domestic passenger flight operating under the provisions of Title 14 CFR Part 121 from ATL to Lafayette Regional Airport (LFT), Lafayette, Louisiana. EDV5526 was holding short of runway 8R on taxiway H waiting for a takeoff clearance. As DAL295 passed behind EDV5526 on taxiway E, its right wingtip impacted the vertical stabilizer of EDV5526, resulting in substantial damage to the CRJ-900 and minor damage to the A350 (see figure 1).
Figure 1. The damaged empennage of EDV5526. (Source: Atlanta Department of Aviation) At the time of the accident, runway 9L was normally used for larger aircraft but was closed for construction. Therefore, DAL295 was scheduled to depart from runway 8R. After pushback from the gate, the flight crew of DAL295 received taxi instructions to proceed north on taxiway D and hold short of taxiway G. DAL295 taxied as instructed and received further instructions to taxi on taxiway G and to hold short of taxiway F.
They were subsequently cleared to taxi on taxiway F and to transition to taxiway E. After DAL295 turned onto taxiway E, ground control instructed the flight crew to have the airplane follow EDV5526 on taxiway E and to switch to the airport traffic control tower’s (ATCT) frequency. As DAL295 continued to taxi on taxiway E, the flight crew observed a navigational alert message, "NAV GNSS-2,” on the lower electronic centralized aircraft monitor (ECAM). The first officer (FO) informed the tower that they would need to stop to coordinate with maintenance before departure. ATC instructed the flight crew to continue straight ahead on taxiway E and to hold short of taxiway V to troubleshoot the problem (see figure 2).
Figure 2. Ground position tracks for DAL295 and EDV5526 in relation to taxiways E and H. The white circle denotes the location of the collision. In this image, both airplanes were traveling from the right to the left on taxiway E.
The captain of DAL295 recalled that, as the airplane approached the intersection with taxiway V, he was focused on ensuring the left wingtip was not impinging on traffic that was coming off of taxiway V. The FO of DAL295 stated he was looking at the navigation display’s Airport Navigation Function and his EFB to identify taxiway V, and was querying the captain about taxiway V. Around that time, the right wingtip of DAL295 impacted the vertical stabilizer of EDV5526, which was holding short of runway 8R at taxiway H. Following the collision, the captain of DAL295 stopped the airplane and set the parking brake. After airport rescue and firefighting (ARFF) examined the exterior of the airplane, the flight crew of DAL295 was given clearance to return to the gate.
The flight crew of EDV5526 stated they pushed back from the gate and that ground control instructed them to taxi to runway 8R via taxiway E. The flight crew completed the “before takeoff” checks while on taxiway E, and ATC advised the crew that DAL295 would wait for them and to monitor the ATCT’s frequency for takeoff. The captain stated she maneuvered the airplane to the hold short line on taxiway H, set the parking brake, and awaited further instruction from ATC (see figure 3).
Figure 3. Ground position tracks of DAL295 and EDV5526 leading up to the collision.
Based on the distance of the nose landing gear of EDV5526 to the hold short line on taxiway H, EDV5526 was about 56 ft from the hold short line (see figure 4). The wingtip distance of DAL295 was estimated to be about 106 ft from the centerline of taxiway E.
Figure 4. The estimated distance of EDV5526 from the hold short line on taxiway H and the estimated distance of the wingtip of DAL295 from the centerline of taxiway E.
Crew Information DAL295 Flight Crew The captain was hired by Delta Air Lines on November 8, 1990, and received his initial type rating on the A350 on January 20, 2023. The FO was hired by Delta Air Lines on November 1, 1996, and received his initial type rating on the A350 on May 20, 2018. EDV5526 Flight Crew The captain was hired by Endeavor Air on September 3, 2019, and received her initial type rating for the CRJ-900 on November 12, 2019.
The FO was hired by Endeavor Air on April 17, 2023, and received his initial type rating for the CRJ-900 on June 30, 2023.
Damage to Aircraft The empennage of the CRJ-900 remained attached to the fuselage by the flight control cables, electrical wiring, and a small section of vertical stabilizer skin. The left side of the aft fuselage exhibited dents and deformation above and below the pylon structure. The right side of the aft fuselage showed two areas of tensile deformation resulting in imprinting of the underlying frames on the skin.
Damage to the right wing of the A350 was limited to the outboard section, starting near the outboard end of the outboard slat and continuing up to the winglet. Blue paint transfer and scrape damage was observed in the outboard section of the right wing.
Flight Recorders The cockpit voice recorder (CVR) and flight data recorder (FDR) from both airplanes were downloaded and analyzed in conjunction with Automatic Dependent Surveillance-Broadcast (ADS-B) data. The estimated time of collision between the two airplanes was at 1007:46 EDT. EDV5526 was stationary and DAL295 was taxiing at a groundspeed of about 12 knots. EDV5526 sustained lateral accelerations of 0.5 gravitational force equivalent (g) left followed by 0.55g right, and its heading had rotated about 9° clockwise. The flight crew of DAL295 exclaimed surprise when the collision occurred and was not aware of what they collided with. After the collision, the flight crew of DAL295 stated they were on the centerline of the taxiway and that they were following their taxi instructions. Immediately after the collision, the captain of EDV5526 stated they thought another aircraft had collided with them and later commented that they “can’t pull forward anymore” in reference to their location to the hold short line.
Additional Information The visibility of the A350 wingtips from the captain and FO seats was assessed by investigators. This assessment determined that the pilots would have to get out of their seats in order to see the wingtips from the cockpit’s aft-most windows. Due to parallax of looking aft and slight distortion from the thick glass of the window, the assessment determined that it would be difficult to assess if the wingtip had adequate clearance to a nearby airplane if a crewmember were to look out of the aft-most window.
Safety Actions After this accident, Delta Air Lines published a reminder to crews in an internal newsletter about remaining vigilant during ground operations, particularly in identifying new threats as they may appear. Delta also added information in the flight operations manual regarding areas of vulnerability during ground operations, to include individual crewmembers announcing when they are “heads down” to perform certain tasks that reduce their ability to monitor outside the cockpit.
Probable cause
Delta Air Lines flight crew’s loss of situation awareness of the clearance between their right wingtip and the empennage of an Endeavor Air airplane holding on a perpendicular taxiway, resulting in their wingtip colliding with the other airplane’s empennage. Contributing to the collision was the Endeavor Air flight crew stopping too far from the hold short line, resulting in insufficient clearance for the Delta Air Lines airplane to pass. The National Transportation Safety Board determined the probable cause of this accident.
Circumstances
- Event type
- Accident
- Highest injury
- Minor
- Weather conditions
- Visual Meteorological Cond
- Light condition
- Not Reported
- Sky condition
- NONE
- Ceiling (ft)
- 0
- Visibility (sm)
- 11.5
- Wind direction
- 60
- Wind speed (kt)
- 5
- Temperature (F)
- 72
- Nearest airport
- Hartsfield-Jackson Atlanta Int
- Distance from field
- 0.94999999
- Airport elevation
- 1026
Aircraft
| Registration | Make | Model | Damage | FAR part |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| N503DN | — | — | MINR | 121 |
| N302PQ | BOMBARDIER INC | CL-600-2D24 | SUBS | 121 |
Sequence of events
| # | Occurrence | Phase |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Taxi-to runway Ground collision defining | Taxi |
| 1 | Taxi-to runway Ground collision defining | Taxi |