N444RJ Cessna 401A accident

NTSB LAX95LA232 · 1995-07-01 · VAN NUYS, CA · near VNY

Docket — crew, injuries and powerplant

Summary

THE AIRCRAFT WAS MAKING A RIGHT-HAND TURN IN THE RUN-UP AREA AT A SLOW SPEED WHEN THE LEFT MAIN LANDING GEAR COLLAPSED. THE SIDE BRACE FOR THE MAIN LANDING GEAR IS ATTACHED TO A CASTING, WHICH IN TURN IS BOLTED TO THE INBOARD WING RIB IN THE LANDING GEAR WHEEL WELL. EXAMINATION REVEALED THAT THE WING RIB WEB CRACKED AROUND THE CASTING, WHICH ALLOWED THE SIDE BRACE TO MOVE AND THE LANDING GEAR TO COLLAPSE. PORTIONS OF THE CRACK APPEARED DISCOLORED AND OLD. REVIEW OF THE AIRCRAFT MAINTENANCE RECORDS REVEALED NO HISTORY OF LANDING GEAR DAMAGE OR HARD LANDING RELATED MAINTENANCE ACTIVITY. THE AIRCRAFT WAS LAST INSPECTED DURING AN ANNUAL INSPECTION 7 MONTHS AND 60 FLIGHT HOURS PRIOR TO THE ACCIDENT. CESSNA AIRCRAFT COMPANY REPORTED THAT IN RESPONSE TO CRACKS FOUND ON THE INBOARD WING RIB WEB AROUND THE SIDE BRACE FITTING, SERVICE LETTER ME76-2 WAS ISSUED ON JANUARY 5, 1976. THE LETTER DETAILS THE INSTALLATION OF A STEEL REINFORCEMENT/DOUBLER PLATE ON THE WING RIB WEB BEHIND THE LANDING GEAR SIDE BRACE FITTING. INSPECTION OF THE AIRCRAFT REVEALED THAT SERVICE LETTER ME76-2 WAS NOT ACCOMPLISHED.

Full narrative

On July 1, 1995, at 0750 hours Pacific daylight time, a Cessna 401A, N444RJ, sustained a left main landing gear collapse while taxiing for departure at Van Nuys, California. The aircraft was owned and operated by the pilot, and was beginning a cross-country flight to Cabo San Lucas, Mexico. Visual meteorological conditions prevailed at the time. The aircraft incurred substantial damage to the left wing, left wing tip fuel tank, and the associated engine and propeller. Neither the certificated private pilot nor his four passengers were injured.

According to the pilot's statement and witness observations, the aircraft was making a right-hand turn in the run-up area at a slow speed when the left main landing gear collapsed.

The side brace for the main landing gear is attached to a casting, which in turn is bolted to the inboard wing rib in the landing gear wheel well. Examination of the aircraft by an FAA airworthiness inspector revealed that the wing rib web cracked around the casting, which allowed the side brace to move and the landing gear to collapse. The inspector reported that portions of the crack appeared discolored and old.

Review of the aircraft maintenance records revealed no history of landing gear damage or hard landing related maintenance activity. The aircraft was last inspected during an annual inspection 7 months and 60 flight hours prior to the accident.

Cessna Aircraft Company was contacted for information regarding known wing rib web failures. Cessna stated that there are no known total landing gear collapse incidents due to cracks in the wing rib web. The company reported that in response to cracks found on the inboard wing rib web around the side brace fitting, Service Letter ME76-2 was issued on January 5, 1976. The letter details the installation of a steel reinforcement/doubler plate on the wing rib web behind the landing gear side brace fitting.

Inspection of the aircraft revealed that Service Letter ME76-2 was not accomplished.

Probable cause

the failure of the wing rib web due to undetected cracking in an area of known crack development around the landing gear side brace fitting. The operator's failure to accomplish a Service Letter addressing the problem is a factor in the accident. The National Transportation Safety Board determined the probable cause of this accident.

Circumstances

Event type
Accident
Highest injury
None
Weather conditions
Visual Meteorological Cond
Light condition
Day
Sky condition
NONE
Ceiling (ft)
0
Visibility (sm)
3
Wind direction
0
Temperature (F)
68
Nearest airport
VAN NUYS
Distance from field
0.0
Airport elevation
799

Aircraft

RegistrationMakeModelDamageFAR part
N444RJ CESSNA 401A SUBS 091

Sequence of events

#OccurrencePhase
1 190 Cruise

Findings

Finding
10102 cause
10401
24119 factor