N2119N Piper PA 28RT-201 accident

NTSB GAA16CA106 · 2016-01-19 · Terrell, TX · near 1F7

Docket — crew, injuries and powerplant

Summary

The flight instructor reported that the private pilot receiving instruction was flying a simulated engine failure approach to an airport in gusty crosswind conditions. When the airplane approached 50 feet above the ground on final, the flight instructor called "go-around." He reported that the instructed pilot "simultaneously pulled back and went full throttle." The flight instructor stated that the airspeed was about 80 knots, and "the airplane fell straight to the ground" short of the runway. After the impact, the airplane bounced forward onto the runway, the left main landing gear collapsed, and the airplane departed the runway to the left about 550 feet from the runway threshold. The flight instructor reported that he verified that the throttle was full forward before the impact. A postaccident examination revealed substantial damage to the right wing. The flight instructor reported there were no mechanical malfunctions or failures with the airplane that would have precluded normal operation. According to the Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) Airport Facility Directory, trees were listed as an obstacle for the runway used. About the time of the accident, 7 nautical miles southeast of the airport, an automated weather observing system reported wind from 190 true at 13 knots, gusting to 21 knots. The tree line was located upwind and parallel to the airplane's final approach.     The FAA Pilot's Handbook of Aeronautical Knowledge describes effects of obstructions on wind. The handbook states, "It is especially important to be vigilant when flying in or out of airports that have large buildings or natural obstructions located near the runway." The handbook further states, "During the landing phase of flight, an aircraft may 'drop in' due to the turbulent air and be too low to clear obstacles during the approach."

Full narrative

The flight instructor reported that the private pilot receiving instruction was flying a simulated engine failure approach to an airport in gusty crosswind conditions. When the airplane approached 50 feet above the ground on final, the flight instructor called "go-around." He reported that the instructed pilot "simultaneously pulled back and went full throttle." The flight instructor stated that the airspeed was about 80 knots, and "the airplane fell straight to the ground" short of the runway. After the impact, the airplane bounced forward onto the runway, the left main landing gear collapsed, and the airplane departed the runway to the left about 550 feet from the runway threshold. The flight instructor reported that he verified that the throttle was full forward before the impact. A postaccident examination revealed substantial damage to the right wing.

The flight instructor reported there were no mechanical malfunctions or failures with the airplane that would have precluded normal operation.

According to the Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) Airport Facility Directory, trees were listed as an obstacle for the runway used. About the time of the accident, 7 nautical miles southeast of the airport, an automated weather observing system reported wind from 190 true at 13 knots, gusting to 21 knots. The tree line was located upwind and parallel to the airplane's final approach.

The FAA Pilot's Handbook of Aeronautical Knowledge describes effects of obstructions on wind. The handbook states, "It is especially important to be vigilant when flying in or out of airports that have large buildings or natural obstructions located near the runway." The handbook further states, "During the landing phase of flight, an aircraft may "drop in" due to the turbulent air and be too low to clear obstacles during the approach."

Probable cause

The private pilot's exceedance of the airplane's critical angle-of-attack during a go-around in gusting crosswind conditions, which resulted in an aerodynamic stall and a collision with terrain short of the runway. The National Transportation Safety Board determined the probable cause of this accident.

Circumstances

Event type
Accident
Highest injury
None
Weather conditions
Visual Meteorological Cond
Light condition
Day
Ceiling (ft)
0
Visibility (sm)
10
Wind direction
190
Wind speed (kt)
13
Temperature (F)
59
Nearest airport
AIRPARK EAST
Distance from field
0.0
Airport elevation
510

Aircraft

RegistrationMakeModelDamageFAR part
N2119N PIPER PA 28RT-201 SUBS 091

Sequence of events

#OccurrencePhase
1 Approach-VFR go-around Other weather encounter Cruise
2 Approach-VFR go-around Loss of control in flight defining Cruise
3 Approach-VFR go-around Collision with terr/obj (non-CFIT) Cruise
4 Landing-landing roll Abnormal runway contact Cruise
5 Landing-landing roll Runway excursion Cruise

Findings

Finding
Personnel issues-Task performance-Use of equip/info-Aircraft control-Student/instructed pilot cause
Aircraft-Aircraft oper/perf/capability-Performance/control parameters-Climb rate-Not attained/maintained cause
Aircraft-Aircraft oper/perf/capability-Performance/control parameters-Angle of attack-Capability exceeded cause
Personnel issues-Action/decision-Action-Delayed action-Instructor/check pilot cause
Environmental issues-Conditions/weather/phenomena-Wind-Variable wind-Effect on operation factor
Environmental issues-Conditions/weather/phenomena-Wind-Gusts-Effect on operation factor
Environmental issues-Physical environment-Object/animal/substance-Tree(s)-Effect on operation factor